A brief open letter concerning WATCHMEN
To the studios: please don't short your future comic-based properties based on the drop-off in WATCHMEN grosses in the second week. Those of who you thought it would pull in $70M got caught up in the excitement and forgot to factor in that it's an R-rated picture with a 2:40 run-time whose core audience are the hard-core comic book fans. The fact it pulled in $55.2M on a non-holiday weekend with those strictures is pretty cool. Between the IMAX release pulling in second-time viewers (such as myself) and the inevitable waves of DVD releases this will likely make money.
(the Fox settlement and issues with certain producers aside.)
To the hater-fanboys: Please shut up about how the movie wasn't exactly like the comic book. You finally got the most faithful adaptation of a comic book you're ever going to get. Endless anonymous online whining about how it didn't capture every nuance of the comic is pointless and ultimately self-defeating. We all know how complex and involved the entirety of the original comic is, and we all should be grown-up enough to understand there's no way a movie can accomplish everything. I flipped through my copy of the trade-paperback when I got back home on opening night, and realized just how much of that comic is really in the screen story. It's amazing, really, particularly if you know anything about the Hollywood development process. If you care about future adaptations, please shut up.
Having said that: be sure to check out the inevitable super-extended DVD which will include the screen story from the theatrical release spliced in with Tales of the Black Freighter and Under The Hood. That will be as close as any movie will ever get to capturing the entirety of that seminal work.
To the fans that enjoyed WATCHMEN: tell your friends. Let them know this is based on a comic so well-written and complex it made TIME Magazine's list of 20 greatest novels of the 20th century. It's been a major influence across the world of comics and in turn the rest of the popular media ever since it debuted in 1986. Help get them interested enough to buy the trade-paperback so we can boost comic sales. Maybe get a few folks to give comics another try.
You should probably also warn them not to take their kids. This is an R-rated movie based on a comic book written for adults with adult-themes and mature subject matter. And a glowing blue man who runs around naked for most of the movie (wearing clothes far less often than he did in the comic, I noticed).
(the Fox settlement and issues with certain producers aside.)
To the hater-fanboys: Please shut up about how the movie wasn't exactly like the comic book. You finally got the most faithful adaptation of a comic book you're ever going to get. Endless anonymous online whining about how it didn't capture every nuance of the comic is pointless and ultimately self-defeating. We all know how complex and involved the entirety of the original comic is, and we all should be grown-up enough to understand there's no way a movie can accomplish everything. I flipped through my copy of the trade-paperback when I got back home on opening night, and realized just how much of that comic is really in the screen story. It's amazing, really, particularly if you know anything about the Hollywood development process. If you care about future adaptations, please shut up.
Having said that: be sure to check out the inevitable super-extended DVD which will include the screen story from the theatrical release spliced in with Tales of the Black Freighter and Under The Hood. That will be as close as any movie will ever get to capturing the entirety of that seminal work.
To the fans that enjoyed WATCHMEN: tell your friends. Let them know this is based on a comic so well-written and complex it made TIME Magazine's list of 20 greatest novels of the 20th century. It's been a major influence across the world of comics and in turn the rest of the popular media ever since it debuted in 1986. Help get them interested enough to buy the trade-paperback so we can boost comic sales. Maybe get a few folks to give comics another try.
You should probably also warn them not to take their kids. This is an R-rated movie based on a comic book written for adults with adult-themes and mature subject matter. And a glowing blue man who runs around naked for most of the movie (wearing clothes far less often than he did in the comic, I noticed).
